Mixed Feelings: White Enough

by Mikka Macdonald | February 4, 2019 7:11 pm

Graphic created by Mikka Kei Macdonald

“I don’t look black, I’m not treated black, but I feel black. I know I’m white-passing and frankly, it’s frustrating,” said James, 32. “I feel like I’m whitewashing my own family away.”

And he’s not alone.

America’s diversity continues to increase, and more and more people are identifying as mixed race; but the concept of ‘white-passing’ and the struggle to define identity in a world dominated by whiteness is not new. White-passing has been used throughout American history to describe someone who, despite some or all of their non-white ancestry, looks white.

Even with this increasing diversity and array of backgrounds and identity, the experiences of those of us who are often considered white-passing are similar: uncertainty about how people racially categorize you; discomfort for “coming out” as non-white; and the haunting guilt that you’re disrespecting your family by not presenting as your actual race(s).

One of the complicating factors of multiracial people’s experience is that other people’s reactions to race vary widely from muddled confusion to ignorantly offensive. As a half-Japanese, half-white adult, I have heard everything from, “obviously you’re white” to “I visited China last year, your food is great!” to “where in Mexico are you from?”

“One of the few ways I know someone doesn’t realize I’m black is if they make jokes about [black] culture, I mention my black family member, and then they apologize,” said Ryan, 26. “It can be weird. But I mean, what am I supposed to do? Shake someone’s hand and say, ‘Nice to meet you. I’m Ryan and, you should know, I’m black’?”

White-passing people often carry the burden of having to explain their race, and for many, that burden is eased by just pretending to be white. For me, it feels like racism’s enduring claws are reaching into the past, white-washing the people in our families who have already passed away, working to rub out their existence, even in death.

“I don’t correct people who think I’m white. I don’t want my peers thinking I’m different. Or, I didn’t want my peers [to know] I was different,” said one woman who is white-passing and wished to stay anonymous for this article. “But I also feel like I’m hiding my family from the world.”  On one hand, presenting as white can shelter you from a slew of American-bred racism. On the other hand, for some, it can feel like denouncing the heritage that might define you.

These circumstances vary from person to person. No one looks the same, no one’s environment is the same, no one reacts the same. In response to the concept of white-passing, perhaps we can begin by being unafraid to bring our full selves into any conversation.

“I don’t know, for me, my solution is to not be afraid of referencing my blackness. If people are confused, that’s their problem,” said Tess, 30, who half-black and half-white. “I’m not trying to fit into their molds or their categories.”

When we allow white-passing to label us, it’s as if white is the noun and every other race is an adjective that orbits around it; it’s as if white is the independent factor; it’s as if white is the norm. As we’re trying to chip away at racism, we should not let racism-based labels restrict or define us.

I don’t know when I’m white-passing or when I’m not, but I’m trying not to let my uncertainty affect how I act. I know my own race and my own identity and I am proud of who I am and where I came from. 

There’s a lot to talk about here. Mixed Feelings is a series about race and identity in America. You can read part one here.

Related Articles

Storytelling at the center of racial healing 

The way we tell stories colors how we remember our own experiences and eventually the longer history of how we fit in society. Repeating these stories leaves a mark on […]

A Letter to My Daughter: Dear Baby Girl, It’s Okay to Feel Scared Right Now

  My 9-year-old daughter is questioning a lot of what is going on in our world right now. I explain to her the importance of Black Lives Matter and answer […]

Mixed Race: Racism and Anti-Blackness

In the United States, race is still a social construct that shapes how other people treat you. No matter how you may personally identify, how someone else sees you can […]

Mixed Feelings: Exploring Multiracial Identity in America

Race has always been a defining issue of this country: an undercurrent, bubbling up to tension points, changing and pushing the country in different directions. In 2019, race is at […]

Hate Has No Home Here

Last week was the anniversary of the deadly Unite the Right Rally in Charlottesville and the neighborhoods of Washington, D.C. were tense. I was tense. The group of white supremacists […]

This Land Is Our Land: Diversity and Access in the Great Outdoors

The United States’ National Park Service and wilderness recreation industry have never been more popular—and yet the American outdoor space is still largely and systematically out of reach for people […]


Join Us